The main mistake in murder of the royal family

There are two versions of the official investigation into the murder of Emperor Nicholas 2 and members of his family .The first version  based on the White Guard 's 1918-1925 investigation conducted by investigators N.A.Sokolov. According to this version  2 Emperor Nicholas , his wife and children were shot in the basement of the Ipatiev House at night from 6 to 17 July 1918. Then their bodies were transported to abandoned mines near Ganina Yama near the city of Yekaterinburg, where they were burned .


The second version is based on the investigation of 1991-2015 years under the supervision of the investigator V.N.Soloveva . This version is based on the "Note Yurovsky ."According to the "Note " Emperor Nicholas 2 , his wife and children were shot in the basement of the Ipatiev House at night from 6 to 17 July 1918. Then their bodies were transported to abandoned mines near Ganina Yama near the city of Yekaterinburg and dropped into one of the mines. Apart from the two bodies that were burned : the body of Tsarevich Alexei and Grand Duchess Maria 's body .

Unfortunately , there is no version an alternative to both official - another version of the murder of Ipatiev scenario captives home to rescue someone from the royal family.  After reviewing available today in the media investigation into the murder of the royal family materials have every reason to believe that they have evidence of the existence of alternative versions .

Consider the evidence:


1. Evidence of the female part of the family evacuated from Ekaterinburg to the area Ganina Yama .


1.1.The fact of finding a corpse in the abandoned mines of the female dog .


The only not precious , but the important material evidence in the criminal case are pets, children belonging to the royal couple. It - Jimmy the dog , which belonged to the Grand Duchess Anastasia Romanova and a dog Spaniel Tsarevich Alexei .From the investigation materials NA Sokolov seen that the corpse dog Jamie was found July 25, 1919 at the bottom of the open mine . In dog he had a broken foot and broken skull , which caused her death. A Spaniel Tsarevich Alexei remained alive in the House of Ipatiev . Dog after the shooting of the guard took it M.I.Lemetin. Somehow all the investigators who conducted the investigation the fact of being at the bottom of an abandoned dog Jimmy's corpse mine is seen as the main proof of the murder of the royal family. A left Tsarevich Alexei dead dog nobody considers evidence that the royal family was not shot .In this case , as described Ya.Yurovskim special care of the dog corpse transported from the basement of the Ipatiev House to the bottom of the mine , it looks as allowance for persons suffering from senile dementia.The conclusion that pets always follow their masters only if they are alive , none of the investigators could not. Although it is pets as involuntary witnesses of the events  are material evidence capable of solve the mystery of the Yekaterinburg tragedy. So dumb pets disclose a murder mystery : the male part of the captives Ipatiev House was killed in the basement and the female part has been taken to destroy the mine. Negligent with pets , the killer made mistakes , disregarding the most important evidence in criminal proceedings .


1.2 Fact finding personal items that prisoners Houses Ipatief usually took with them on a long journey.


Another proof of the fact of the evacuation of the female part of the family are found near the mine things belonging to the royal family , which they took to the road (Saints samples , cardboard box, bottles with salts , candles , bags , etc.).

The main evidence that the female part of the family was not upset in the House of Ipatiev is to find pieces of women's corsets in which no traces of bullets and bayonet. That is the conclusion reached by the authors of the book A. Summers and T.Mangold "The case of the Romanovs or the execution which was not " ( published in Russian in 2011 , Moscow , Algorithm ). Their opinion is confirmed by the conclusions of American experts .


13. Documents confirming the evacuation of Emperor Nicholas 2 family members


These documents are the following telegram:

1. On July 17, 1918 . From Yekaterinburg from A.G. Beloborodova Secretary N.P. Gorbunov for Y.M.Sverdlov:
"Tell Sverdlov the whole family is killed during the evacuation "(«Передаите Свердлову что все семеиство постигла та же участь что и главу оффициально семия погибнет при евакуации»).

2. From July 1918 . From Yekaterinburg by the Presidium of the Ural Regional Council of Deputies . This telegram was found Sept. 5, 1918 investigator I. Sergeyev:
" Romanov family was held together with him in custody , evacuated from the city of Yekaterinburg in the interest of public safety" .

3. On July 17, 1918 . From Yekaterinburg of the Presidium of the VI Regional Council Lenin and YM SverdlovThis message says about " Emperor Nicholas II in connection with the shooting of " White Guard plot " , and that his family had " evacuated to a safe place . "


As can be seen , the three cables point to the fact the evacuation of the royal family ( wife and children ) from Yekaterinburg .The official text of the verdict , published a week after the shooting in Perm , also points to the execution only of Emperor Nicholas 2 on the night of 16 of July 17, 1918 and the evacuation of his family. The materials of the criminal investigation there are no documents confirming the fact of the execution or evacuation of persons approached to Emperor Nicholas 2. Based on the content of official documents  can be concluded that the July 16, 1918 , was shot only 2 Emperor Nicholas and his family were evacuated from the city of Yekaterinburg .Despite these facts , both the investigator denied that the evacuation of the royal family of the Ipatiev house , basing his version on the contradictory testimony of guards and assassins .


2. Evidence of the impact of legislative reform on the fate of the royal family


The most important omission of the investigators in the investigation of the murder of the royal family is the lack of analysis of the impact of legislative reform on the tragic fate of the royal family .The materials of both the consequences of the lack of historical analysis conducted in Moscow the fifth All-Russian Congress of Soviets from 4 to 10 July 1918 . Investigators N.A. Sokolov and V.N.Solovev has not assessed the consequences of the Romanov dynasty , adopted by the Congress of the following normative - legal acts:


1. The Constitution of the RSFSR of 10 July 1918, which was established the dictatorship of the proletariat based on the suppression and destruction of the ruling class;

2. Decree of 13 July 1918 the Council of People's Commissars "On the nationalization of the property of the deposed Russian emperor and members of the former Imperial House " from 13 July 1918 .


The fact that the Fifth All-Russian Congress of Soviets from 4 to 10 July 1918 had a special significance in the fate of the royal family .After all, the July 4, 1918 was appointed commandant Ya.Yurovskogo , and for internal security Ipatiev House attracted the KGB. This fact is directly linked with the forthcoming departure to Moscow and her adoption of the first Constitution .The draft constitution was charged for its development Resolution of the Central Executive Committee of the Commission more April 1 (March 19 ) in 1918. Therefore , members of the forthcoming Congress of Soviets were well aware of his agenda - on the constitutional recognition of Soviet power.

In the history of the adoption of the decree on the nationalization of 13 July 1918 and the Constitution of July 10, 1918 , there is another important fact. Both pieces of legislation have been published in the media only July 19, 1918. This means that in the force they entered only on the day of the burial of the remains of the royal family. And that all actions with the violence of the representatives of the Russian Imperial House ( in Yekaterinburg and Alapayevsk ) have been implemented by the date of entry into force of the above acts. This confirms the fact that the Urals authorities had acted on the orders of the Moscow authorities, prepared the publication of the July 19, 1918 the Constitution of July 10 and the Decree on the nationalization of 13 July .