Eternal Question

Лирика была предоставлена мне для написания песни, с целью дальнейшего троллинга, но я обычно всегда сообщаю авторам стихов о том что была написана песня на их лирику, если это не мои стихи, как оказалось это лирика Натальи Филипповой, которой данный "товарищ" делал видеоролик. Близко с её творчеством не знаком, но рахзыскал её страницу в сети и дал ссылки на песни написаные по её лирике, включая и мои украинскоязычные каверы-ответы...

Eternal Question – © 2025 (Natalia Filippova lyrics) v.2.3

( https://suno.com/s/UcAt1WZv4PdjaheR )
( https://suno.com/s/ZAq3gSBZceiKAPnY )

[Style: Cinematic Jazz Ballad with Electronic & Rock, Tempo 78–96 BPM, Emotional, atmospheric, rhythmically alive, Minor key, modal tension, ]
[Vocal: Male baritone, firm, slightly cracked/raspy, strong emotional intensity, clear articulation, dramatic phrasing, expressive dynamics, no softness, ]
[Language: Russian]
[Emotion & mood: sorrowful, protesting, intimate yet powerful, Expresses emotional fatigue, war horror, peace desire, Builds from mournful verses to dramatic instrumental outbursts, ]
[Post-production:]
[Mix: hard separation of melodic and percussive layers, Rhodes and guitar centered, pads wide, war instruments deep and compressed, ]
[Reverb: plate on vocals, hall on Rhodes, long cinematic tail on synths, ]
[Automation: synth swells and pad expansions at emotional peaks, texture drops before fanfares, ]
[FX: thunder, reversed breath FX, wind noise layers, low static during fanfare buildup, tail cuts on cello and brass]

[Instruments:]
[Rhodes piano: harmonic foundation, melodic support, Em9-based voicings, midrange-focused, long reverb.]
[Ambient analog synth (Juno-60 for pad, Prophet-5 for harmonics): background texture, emotional sustain, high-register shimmer, evolving swells.]
[Electric jazz guitar: melodic counterpoint, echoing responses, minor pentatonic voicings, spaced phrases, clean tone for verses, overdriven for fanfares.]
[Fretless bass: legato root motion, modal colors, clean warm tone, driving rhythm in fanfares, sparse in verses.]
[Drum kit: soft brushes for lyrical parts, heavy toms and war rolls for fanfares, deep ambient snare, impactful kicks.]
[Cello: expressive melodic war themes, tremolo and glissando for tension, deep emotional impact, long sustained notes for sorrow.]
[Orchestral brass (samples): war fanfare stabs, low brass weight with distortion for intensity, brief, impactful phrases.]
[Chord progressions:]
[Main vocal: (Em9–Bm11–Am7–Cmaj7–Dmaj9–Bm7–Em9)]
[War fanfares: (C#m7b5–Em–G–F#7sus4–B7–Em(add9))]

[Synth pad (Juno-60): Right hand: (Em9), (Bm11), (Am7), (Cmaj7), (Dmaj9), (Bm7), (Em9) voicings. Left hand: Bass roots (E–B–A–C–D–B–E). Held notes with slight swells and reverb tails.]
[War brass/cello (Prophet-5 + cello): (C#m7b5): (C#–E–G–B) | (Em): (E–G–B) | (G): (G–B–D) | (F#7sus4): (F#–B–E) | (B7): (B–D#–F#–A) | (Em(add9)): (E–G–B–F#).]

[Intro – instrumental]
[Thunder FX. Cellos in tremolo play (C#m7b5–Em). Brass enters in short bursts with (G) and (B7). War drums pulse in quarter notes: low tom – pause – snare roll – silence. Pads drone low (Em) root.]

[Verse 1: male vocal]
[Rhodes plays (Em9–Bm11–Am7–Cmaj7). Guitar enters in call/response with vocal phrases, delayed. Synths in background shimmer (Juno-60 pad). Bass glides stepwise with root and fifths.]
[Drums: soft brushes on snare and light kick on 2/4.]
Мы пережили трагедии все по Шекспиру,
Сыты театрами действий военных вполне.
Что в этом мире мешает стабильному миру? –
Чёткий ответ уложить не дано в голове

[Chorus – male vocal]
[Chords: (Dmaj9–Bm7–Em9–Cmaj7–Dmaj9–Em9). Synths expand slightly, add bright overtone layer. Guitar plays upward arpeggios. Vocal becomes more expressive, slightly louder. Bass outlines full chords with glides.]
Войны, как ветры, они никогда не стихали –
От сотворенья не знает покоя Земля.
Вместо ракет лучше б полнили небо стихами,
Вместо сирен запускали б в эфир соловья.

[Instrumental – war fanfare I]
[Tempo 6/8. Cello plays melodic figure in (Em–G–F#7sus4–B7). Brass hits with delay, overlapping cello. Bass drones (F#) and (B) alternately. Drums: low tom triplets and layered snare.]
[Synth: Prophet-5 noise swell over final (Em(add9)) hit.]

[Verse 2 – male vocal]
[Return to Rhodes arpeggios and softer mix. Synth pad uses (Em9) voicing held with filter modulation. Guitar less active.]
Что за ужасный набор хромосом в человеке,
Кто ДНК изменил, что её не узнать? –
Ныне и присно и, видимо, даже вовеки
Будет живое живых, возгордясь, убивать.

[Chorus – male vocal]
[Same harmonic structure. Add low cello sustains beneath.]
[FX: slight battlefield noise in background.]
Войны, как ветры, они никогда не стихали,
От сотворенья не знает покоя Земля.
Вместо ракет лучше б полнили небо стихами,
Вместо сирен запускали б в эфир соловья.

[Instrumental – war fanfare II]
[Expanded fanfare. Cellos play octave glissandi. Drums heavier, use reverb.]
[Chords: (C#m7b5–Em–F#7sus4–G–B7–Em(add9)). Synth brass stabs overlap with cello runs. Pad swells removed momentarily.]

[Verse 3: male vocal]
[Minimal instrumentation: Rhodes + ambient pad. Drums nearly silent. Fretless bass returns. Guitar re-enters mid-phrase.]
Тонет Звезда Вифлеема в бесчувственной Лете,
Новый мессия несёт непростительный бред…
Гамлет, в изношенных берцах и бронежилете
С вечным вопросом встречает в окопе рассвет…

[Outro – instrumental + final vocal echo]
[Reprise (Em(add9)) theme. Guitar plays descending line on (Em) pentatonic. Pad holds long root.]
[Vocal repeats: “Вместо сирен запускали б в эфир соловья” as distant reverberated phrase. Ends on cello harmonic (E) and silence.]

      ~*~
Eternal Question – © 2025 (Natalia Filippova lyrics) v.3.5

( https://suno.com/s/yMLcgkOp0YeHePFr )

[Music style: Art Rock, Post-Punk with New Wave, Electronic Ambient, Moody, driving rhythm, sparse expressive instrumentation, ]
[Key: Em]
[Time signature: 4/4]
[Tempo: 90 BPM]
[Vocal style male: Baritone, firm, raspy tone, emotional grit, natural roughness, no sweetness or softness, ]
[Vocal style female: Ethereal, melancholic, clear, powerful, smooth phrasing, dramatic, ]

[Instruments:]
[Rhodes piano: harmonic foundation, melodic, (Em9)-based voicings, midrange, reverb, ]
[Ambient synth: pads, textures, shimmer, (Juno-60) for pads, (Prophet-5) for brass-like hits, ]
[Electric guitar: melodic counterpoint, clean for verses, overdriven for pre-chorus/solo, ]
[Fretless bass: legato root motion, driving rhythm, ]
[Drum kit: soft brushes for verses, impactful kicks, heavy tom rolls for pre-chorus, ]
[Cello: expressive melody, tremolo, glissando, deep impact]

[Post-production:]
[Mix: clear separation, Rhodes/guitar centered, pads wide. Bass/drums strong.]
[Reverb: plate on vocals, hall on Rhodes, long on synths/cello.]

[Chords & Tab Assignments:]
[Em9: (E–G–B–D–F#) (Rhodes piano, guitar arpeggio)]
[Bm11: (B–D–F#–A–C#) (Fretless bass, pads)]
[Am7: (A–C–E–G) (Electric guitar chords, clean tone)]
[Cmaj7: (C–E–G–B) (Synth pads, soft strings)]
[Dmaj9: (D–F#–A–C#–E) (Chorus electric guitar, backing synth)]
[Bm7: (B–D–F#–A) (Bass, low synth)]

[Lyrics & Chords with vocal assignment]

[Verse 1: Male vocal]
[Em9]Мы пережили трагедии все по [Bm11]Шекспиру.
[Am7]Сыты театрами действий военных [Cmaj7]вполне.
[Em9]Что в этом мире мешает стабильному [Bm11]миру?
[Am7]Чёткий ответ уложить не дано в [Cmaj7]голове.

[Pre-Chorus Instrumental:]
[Electric guitar solo: minor pentatonic over (Em9–Bm11–Am7–Cmaj7) progression. Aggressive tone.]
[Drums: heavy tom rolls, bass drum accents.]
[Cello: short, mournful glissando.]

[Chorus: Female vocal]
[Dmaj9]Войны, как ветры, они [Bm7]никогда не стихали.
[Em9]От сотворенья не знает [Cmaj7]покоя Земля.
[Dmaj9]Вместо ракет лучше б [Bm7]полнили небо стихами.
[Em9]Вместо сирен запускали [Cmaj7]б в эфир соловья.

[Verse 2: Male vocal]
[Em9]Что за ужасный набор хромосом в [Bm11]человеке!
[Am7]Кто ДНК изменил, что её не [Cmaj7]узнать?
[Em9]Ныне и присно и, видимо, даже [Bm11]вовеки
[Am7]Будет живое живых, возгордясь, [Cmaj7]убивать.

[Pre-Chorus Instrumental:]
[Repeat electric guitar solo & drums as before.]

[Chorus 2: Female vocal]
[Dmaj9]Войны, как ветры, они [Bm7]никогда не стихали.
[Em9]От сотворенья не знает [Cmaj7]покоя Земля.
[Dmaj9]Вместо ракет лучше б [Bm7]полнили небо стихами.
[Em9]Вместо сирен запускали [Cmaj7]б в эфир соловья.

[Verse 3: Male vocal]
[Em9]Тонет Звезда Вифлеема в бесчувственной [Bm11]Лете.
[Am7]Новый мессия несёт непростительный [Cmaj7]бред.
[Em9]Гамлет в изношенных берцах и бронежи[Bm11]лете
[Am7]С вечным вопросом встречает в окопе [Cmaj7]рассвет…

[Outro Instrumental:]
[Rhodes piano arpeggio on (Em9), synth pads (Cmaj7), fretless bass (Bm11), soft brushes on drums, guitar clean melody on (Am7). Fade out with lingering cello harmonic (E).]