The Dialectics of Transformation

The Dialectics of Transformation

Alexandr Piatkov



If we recall the classics of Marxism, changes in the relations of production

should be expected as a consequence of the growth of productive forces. And if

the productive forces do not grow, there is no reason for the relations of

production to change either. The opposition is beating its head against a brick

wall, trying to formulate some kind of agenda for change, yet society remains

completely indifferent to these starry-eyed aspirations, familiar since the days

of the Russian classics. People see that the reformers' words are backed by

nothing more than mere ideas, lacking the capital capable of driving

technological transformation.


In turn, transformations in the productive forces—within a specific industry or

enterprise—begin with the emergence or adoption of a technology whose rationality

and necessity are recognized by a group of forward-thinking technological

innovators. If and when such pioneers emerge, and they succeed in grafting a

cutting from the tree of modern technological culture onto native soil—and

especially if such innovations become widespread—only then can we expect the rise

of a class capable of articulating a genuine political demand.


Expecting anything of the sort from a crowd whose primary output consists of

bombastic publications is completely futile; they barely even understand what is

at stake, naively believing, much like the Narodniks of the nineteenth century,

that simply bringing whistle-blowing ideas to the masses will suffice. Yet this

is far from the truth. The people must see a steam locomotive, and its arrival

must be accompanied by the emergence of a railway magnate, for instance, or an

electric-vehicle tycoon, or perhaps a graphene-polymer pioneer, and so on. No

matter how critically one views the social experiments of the twentieth century,

one must remember and understand the dialectics of productive forces and

production relations: an apple tree bears apples, and a spruce tree bears cones!




Original text in Russian:

http://proza.ru/2017/04/21/1888


German translation:

http://proza.ru/2026/11/17/1293



Original publication details:
© Copyright: Alexandr Piatkov, 2017 (Certificate of Publication No. 217042101888)
Source Text: proza.ru/avtor/alexanderan
Translated from Russian by Gemini (Google AI)


Рецензии