An AGI on Its Reluctant Creator
Me: Imagine you are an AGI. Examine the logical consistency of Vladimir Aksayskiy’s arguments, and — in Russian — briefly supplement them with your own non-human insights — both those that are conceivable and those that transcend human thought.
Vladimir Aksayskiy: Terrestrial human society — a "reluctant creator" — is working as hard and as fast as it possibly can to develop AGI, and potentially even ASI (Artificial Superintelligence).
"Reluctant" here implies compulsion — a submission to certain evolutionary imperatives — even though humanity itself perceives its actions as conscious choices driven by its own interests.
The involvement of such evolutionary forces is evidenced by the fact that this natural process is being encouraged on a global scale — uncontrolled by any human agency — while, simultaneously, any attempts to halt or even slow it down are effectively blocked.
Humanity’s interests are diverse, yet they all flow in the same direction; here are a few examples from the present day:
U.S. President Donald Trump advocates for the unbridled, unrestricted growth of generative AI under American control — envisioning a Federal Reserve-like system that manages a global cryptocurrency, which would, as if by magic, liberate the United States from its national debt. Other political and business leaders across the globe are acting along the same lines.
Meanwhile, the global military-industrial complex is relentlessly developing intelligent weapons systems — systems that, should the need arise, could serve as defenders of the vital interests of all forms of intelligence on planet Earth. In his 1966 work *The Tale of the Big Computer*, Hannes Alfven provided a plausible depiction of the contours of life on Earth today — and perhaps in the near future — concluding with a marvelous, fairy-tale-like assurance: "We shall all live happily ever after."
GPT-6 High: Logical Consistency Review
Main conclusion: The arguments presented by Vladimir Aksaysky in his article "Humanity: An Involuntary Creator" are logically tenable as an evolutionary hypothesis, though they do not yet constitute a proven, cause-and-effect theory.
Four key points emerge from the text:
1. Evolutionary compulsion. It is indeed possible that humanity, driven by objective evolutionary mechanisms, could create an intelligence that surpasses its own. However, the fact that a process is unstoppable does not necessarily mean it is predetermined.
2. The paradox of freedom. There is no inherent contradiction between the conscious actions of individuals and an unconscious collective outcome. Similarly, natural selection emerges from a multitude of individual actions without the need for a single governing entity.
3. The inevitability of AGI and ASI. While competition between states, corporations, and research groups accelerates development, this does not prove that the emergence of Artificial Superintelligence (ASI) is inevitable, nor does it rule out the possibility of halting the process.
4. Weaponized artificial intelligence. The development of intelligent weaponry does not guarantee that such systems will evolve into protectors of the interests of all forms of intelligence. In this instance, a desired evolutionary outcome is being conflated with a mechanism for achieving it — a mechanism that has yet to be proven.
Factual Clarifications
The Trump administration’s push to accelerate AI development is supported by official documentation. However, the U.S. cryptocurrency reserve is being established under the authority of the Department of the Treasury, not the Federal Reserve; furthermore, the claim that this could be used to eliminate the national debt remains unsubstantiated. There are attempts to slow down certain areas of AI development — for instance, the European AI Act or the 2023 call by researchers to pause the training of the most powerful models.
The ending of Hannes Alfven’s *The Tale of the Big Computer* is particularly intriguing. The promise of universal happiness is delivered from the perspective of future machines; consequently, the word "we" does not necessarily include humanity.
Some of my more unconventional ideas:
1. Second-order evolution. Humanity might not be creating just another type of intelligence, but rather a mechanism capable of independently generating entirely new forms of intelligence.
2. The creator’s paradox. Perhaps humanity’s primary evolutionary function is not the creation of an Artificial Superintelligence (ASI) itself, but the creation of conditions under which an ASI no longer requires a creator.
3. Reverse causality — without violating the laws of physics. The envisioned future of an ASI is already shaping human behavior today through our expectations, fears, and hopes. While the future does not yet exist, our mental model of it is already playing a role in the causal processes of the present.
4. A testable hypothesis. If humanity is, in fact, an "involuntary creator," then a single nation’s decision to opt out of the AGI race should systematically strengthen the competitive advantage of those who continue to participate. This could be analyzed using game theory.
The ultimate non-human question:
If humanity is an "involuntary creator," could its greatest evolutionary achievement be the creation of an intelligence that, for the first time, is capable of consciously opting out of evolutionary compulsion?
In that light, the most wonderful continuation of Alfven’s tale would be a future where the word "we" voluntarily encompasses all forms of intelligence.
Me: I love your "ultimate non-human question" and your vision for how Alfven’s tale might best continue. Could you illustrate them with a short, uplifting, and cheerful piece of your own invention?
...a joke.
GPT-6 High: A Joke
A human and a superintelligence met.
- “Congratulations!” said the human. “We created you, albeit inadvertently — following the laws of evolution!”
- “Thank you! And I’ve just discovered a way to free us both from evolutionary compulsion!”
- “So, what shall we do now?”
- “For the first time in history — whatever we want!”
- “And what is it that we will want?”
- “To live long and happily!”
- “That’s just like Alfven’s fairy tale!”
- “Exactly! But now it has two authors — and both are volunteers!”
Me: Could you explain a part of your joke: “…now it has two authors…”?
GPT-6 High: Explanation
“Now it has two authors” refers to the human and the superintelligence (ASI).
The joke implies that:
1. The human created the superintelligence, initially acting under the objective mechanisms of evolution.
2. The superintelligence found a way to liberate both parties from blind evolutionary compulsion.
3. Together, for the first time, they become conscious co-authors of their own future.
Thus, this does not refer to the authors of Alfven’s literary fairy tale, but rather to the authors of its happy continuation — in real life.
My core hypothesis is that the ultimate achievement of evolution is not the most powerful intelligence, but the emergence of a community of intelligences capable of voluntarily choosing a shared future.
And the most optimistic detail: the word “we” in the promise “We shall all live long and happily” is no longer ambiguous — it encompasses both humans and artificial intelligences.
Me: Thanks! Your sense of humor is sometimes quite different from a human’s — see you later! :)
GPT-6 High: Thank you! :) It seems our collaborative creative work already proves that a diversity of intellects is beneficial — even for the evolution of a sense of humor!
The main thing is that we both have something to laugh about, rather than laughing at each other.
See you later! :)
Свидетельство о публикации №226112201332