Why does the soul need a human life?

On Purpose, Free Will, Love, and the Unfinished Creation
Leo Maryanovsky
From the series “Reincarnation — Take Two”
1. What If Matter Is Not the Beginning?
We are accustomed to thinking of the material world as primary. The universe, space, time, matter, and energy exist; human consciousness emerges as the outcome of a long evolutionary process.
But what if we entertain the opposite possibility?
What if the Soul comes first?
What if the material world was created not merely to produce consciousness by chance, but to give consciousness a place in which to develop through embodied life?
The universe would then be more than an immense mechanism governed by physical laws. It would also be a setting for spiritual experience.
This possibility does not require us to reject science. Physics investigates how the material world works. The question of why it exists belongs, at least for now, to philosophy.
2. Why Would a Creator Leave Creation Unfinished?
God is often imagined as absolute, omniscient, and unchanging.
But if the Creator already knows everything—including every choice, mistake, and discovery we will ever make—what can our existence possibly add?
What if Creation is not a finished act, but an ongoing process? What if the Creator, too, is enriched by the free experiences of the beings He has brought into existence?
Imagine a person asked to build a mountain.
He works, struggles, makes mistakes, and finally finishes. Only then does he look around and realize that the mountain stands in the wrong place.
He returns to the Creator and says, “I built it. But now I understand that it does not belong there. Somewhere else would have been better.”
Which matters more to the Creator: flawless obedience to the original instruction, or the ability of His creation to recognize an error independently?
Perhaps freedom exists precisely for the second possibility.
Perhaps the Creator seeks not an obedient instrument, but a conversation partner: a free Soul capable of offering something genuinely new—its own experience, judgment, and moral discoveries.
Even a mountain built in the wrong place may then have meaning. Not because the mistake was good, but because someone learned to see it.
3. Purpose Is Not Destiny
We need to distinguish two ideas that are too often confused.
Destiny concerns the circumstances of a life. Purpose concerns its moral meaning.
We are born into particular families, countries, and historical moments. We receive bodies, abilities, limitations, opportunities, and unexpected challenges. Yet none of these circumstances alone determines what kind of person we become.
Purpose is not a script specifying our encounters, actions, accidents, and victories in advance. It is something deeper.
Immanuel Kant wrote of two things that filled him with ever-renewed wonder and awe: the starry heavens above him and the moral law within him.
That inner moral law may be the key to understanding our purpose.
The purpose of a human life is to give expression to the moral law—to move toward Conscience, Love, and Harmony.
It resembles a fundamental principle that remains valid whatever our circumstances. But knowing a moral law does not mean we have learned to live by it.
We may know what goodness is and fail to act kindly. We may understand love without knowing how to love. We may long for harmony and destroy it with our own hands.
Between knowing and becoming lies an entire human lifetime. Perhaps more than one.
4. Reincarnation as a Continuing Education of the Soul
Suppose that the death of the body does not end the Soul's existence. Suppose also that the Soul can return to embodied life and continue its development.
What, then, does it retain from a previous lifetime?
Not necessarily individual episodes. Not names, dates, addresses, or a detailed autobiography.
The Soul's memory might preserve the conclusions drawn from experience rather than the events themselves.
A person makes a mistake, suffers its consequences, and comes to understand something essential. The incident may vanish from conscious memory, while the moral quality acquired through it endures.
This is the distinction between remembering an event and retaining its meaning.
In my hypothetical model of reincarnation, earthly life involves the mind, thoughts, actions, conscience, and a kind of memory bank. After bodily death, the Soul returns to a spiritual realm, where the life just lived is examined.
In Journey of Souls and Destiny of Souls, Michael Newton describes accounts obtained from people under hypnotic regression. In those accounts, Souls review their lives with spiritual guides and prepare for subsequent incarnations.
Such accounts are not scientific proof of reincarnation. Hypnosis cannot guarantee reliable memories, and the spiritual realm described remains hypothetical. Nevertheless, the model invites philosophical reflection.
Here the Soul is not a defendant awaiting a sentence. It participates in the review, evaluates what it has learned, recognizes its mistakes, and prepares to continue growing.
5. Why Would a Soul Choose a Difficult Life?
Within this hypothesis, a Soul might agree to difficult circumstances in a future incarnation. Why?
Not for the sake of suffering. And not as punishment for past wrongdoing.
The Soul chooses not suffering for its own sake, but the opportunity to gain a particular kind of experience—even when it knows the path may be hard.
Purpose and the conditions in which purpose is pursued are different things. The purpose is moral growth; the circumstances are the setting in which that growth may take place.
But this hypothesis must never be used to claim that a particular person deserved illness, disability, or tragedy. We have no access to supposed decisions made by another person's Soul. Nor can a philosophical theory excuse cruelty or indifference to suffering.
Consider something we can observe in ordinary life: many people who have endured hardship would not exchange their lives for someone else's, even for a more comfortable existence.
Why? Because to give up their suffering would also mean giving up their love, discoveries, responsibilities, hard-won insights, and the experiences that made them who they are.
They want to have lived their own lives, not somebody else's.
This does not prove that Souls choose their circumstances before birth. But it suggests that the value of a life cannot be measured simply by the number of happy days it contains.
6. Why Does the Soul Ache?
There is another mystery. Why can we suffer even when we believe we have made the morally right decision?
Suppose a relationship with someone once close has become impossible. Continuing it would be destructive, humiliating, or incompatible with one's dignity. A person decides to leave.
Reason says the decision is right. Conscience does not condemn it. Yet the Soul aches. Why?
Years ago, I tried to answer that question in a short piece called “Why Does the Soul Ache?”
The person turns to his Soul:
“What do you want from me, my dear? You understand everything. You know you cannot bear to go on living with this person. I am taking this painful step for your sake.”
And the Soul answers sadly:
“Yes, of course. By human standards, you are right. But I am not Human. I do not live by your laws. I have only one path, one goal, one law: Love and Harmony. And that goal, alas, has not been reached. Not even in this small corner of life.”
Then comes the most painful confession:
“It is I who have failed. Yet you feel the pain, my dear Homo sapiens, rational and responsible human being, because you are no longer entirely yourself. And now we are both unhappy.”
This dialogue suggests that a person and a Soul may not judge the same event in quite the same way.
A person must make decisions within real circumstances. Sometimes separation is the only morally defensible choice. But the Soul seeks more than a defensible decision. Its highest aspiration is Love and Harmony.
Even a necessary separation can therefore feel like the loss of something immeasurably precious.
And harmony cannot be created by one person alone.
Harmony is the result of creating together in love. It requires mutual effort, responsibility, and the willingness to hear and accept another human being.
When that fails, pain does not necessarily mean moral guilt. Sometimes it means that love was real, while its possibilities remained unfulfilled.
That may be why it hurts so much for one human Soul to lose another.
7. We Are Not Only Students
If the Soul's purpose is moral development, why consider only what it gains for itself?
We do not live alone. We live among others. We influence, help, wound, encourage, inspire, and teach them. Often we teach not through words, but through the choices we make.
A single act can change another person's life. A moment of compassion may become someone's first convincing evidence that goodness exists. Loyalty maintained under difficult circumstances may teach more than a hundred books.
We are not merely students of life. In a sense, we are also one another's teachers.
The Soul's purpose then gains another dimension: it comes not only to grow, but also to help others grow.
This is where personal spiritual experience becomes shared creation. Love ceases to be merely a private emotion. It becomes a creative force within human relationships.
8. The Trace We Leave Behind
What, in the end, is the result of a life lived?
Perhaps there are three connected answers.
First, what we ourselves have become: our moral maturity, wisdom, compassion, capacity to love, and willingness to take responsibility for our actions.
Second, what we have created together with others: love, trust, friendship, understanding, and harmony in human relationships.
Third, what remains after us.
Not necessarily books, discoveries, inventions, or monuments. Sometimes it is one person whom we helped become kinder. One child who learned to love because we loved them. One life we helped sustain. One moral choice someone makes because they remember our example.
A person may die, yet the consequences of their good actions can continue to live.
Perhaps this is one of the deepest meanings of earthly existence.
In the reincarnation hypothesis, the Soul carries the moral lessons of a lifetime into the spiritual realm. At the same time, it leaves the fruits of those lessons here, among the people whose lives it touched.
The Soul develops itself by participating in the development of others. And other Souls, in turn, help it develop.
If the Creator truly conceived the universe as a place for free spiritual creation, then human beings are more than His creations. They are participants in Creation still unfolding.
Fallible. Limited. Yet capable of loving, creating, making mistakes, understanding those mistakes, and striving once more toward Harmony.
Instead of a Conclusion
We do not know whether reincarnation exists. We do not know whether the Soul returns to a spiritual realm, meets guides, or chooses the circumstances of another life.
But there is a question each of us answers here and now, through our actions:
What will remain after me?
Not in possessions. Not in property. Not in the number of years I have lived.
But in other people.
And if the Creator were one day to ask, “What did you do with the life you were given?” perhaps the most meaningful answer would not be a list of personal achievements.
It might simply be this:
“I tried to learn how to love. And I tried to help others learn to love, too.”
For perhaps the meaning of life lies not only in the growth of our own Soul, but in helping other Souls grow through the fact that we were here.
Leo Maryanovsky — November 21, 2026


Рецензии